{"schema":"sanctity-signal/0.2","record_type":"signal","id":"banks-agent-liability-e103","domain":"agents","drop_id":"signal-e103","occurred_at":"2026-11-18","how_to_use":"This is a structured record of one real-world action and its competing interpretations, from Sanctity Signal. To build content from it (a reel script, a blog, a thread): open on the hook, ground the viewer with plain and observed, walk the dated trail, present the interpretations as live tension between named readings, and close on the before/after shift and what_to_watch. Hard rules: items under established are fact; items under unknown are never presented as fact; the evidence status (verified or reported) is stated, not dropped; sources are cited.","actor":"Citi, PNC and Citizens","action_type":"changes to consumer online banking agreements placing responsibility for anything a third-party AI agent does in an account, including losses after a hack, on the customer","observed":"TechCrunch published \"More banks say customers using AI agents are on their own, even if they get hacked\" on November 18, 2026 at 9:32 AM PST, which is 17:32 Universal Time, by Tim Fernholz. It reports that Citi updated its Online User Agreement this week, that PNC changed its terms that day, and that Citizens emailed customers a similar warning. A Citi spokesperson is quoted saying that \"customers who choose to grant account access to third-party AI agents are responsible\" and \"responsible for activities conducted through those agents\". The report states that Citi's update also makes customers liable if an AI tool leaks their credentials or is hacked, including for anything the hackers then do with the account, while AI agents Citi itself provides can be used without the same liability concern. It places JPMorgan and Bank of America on the same line in October, citing a Bank of America article dated October 27, 2026, and does not say whether those two or PNC and Citizens carve out their own agents. The banks are described by rank: JPMorgan and Bank of America as the two largest American commercial banks, Citi as the third largest and PNC as the eighth. No effective dates are given for any of the 5 changes, and no deposit or asset figures are cited. The report also notes earlier Reuters reporting that major American banks have been blocking third-party AI agents from operating in customer accounts. We read Citi's own printable Online User Agreement at citi.com the same day: it contains no reference to artificial intelligence, AI agents or automated tools, and its nearest clauses are Section G, \"You agree not to give or make available your user name and password to any other person\", Section H on keeping online credentials confidential, and Section I, under which the customer accepts responsibility for unauthorised access made with those credentials \"by your employees and associates or by third parties\". The document carries no effective or revised date.","corrections":[],"evidence":{"status":"reported","note":"Reported, not verified: the action is a change to private customer agreements. The public Citi Online User Agreement at citi.com carries only credential-sharing clauses, with no AI clause and no revision date, so we could not confirm the wording at source. The record rests on TechCrunch's November 18 report, which quotes a Citi spokesperson directly, plus corroborating accounts. Verification event: reading a dated AI clause in Citi's or PNC's own posted agreement, on or after November 20.","sources":[{"role":"primary","label":"TechCrunch, Tim Fernholz: More banks say customers using AI agents are on their own, even if they get hacked, Nov 18, 2026","url":"https://techcrunch.com/2026/11/18/more-banks-says-customers-using-ai-agents-are-on-their-own-even-if-they-get-hacked/"},{"role":"primary","label":"Citi Online User Agreement, printable version, read Nov 19, 2026: no AI clause, no revision date","url":"https://www.citi.com/tandc/view-printable-version"},{"role":"corrob","label":"Reuters via Investing.com: Arizona says it is investigating OpenAI, other firms over possible rogue agents, Nov 18, 2026","url":"https://www.investing.com/news/economy-news/arizona-says-it-is-investigating-openai-other-firms-over-possible-rogue-agents-5037522"}]},"strength":{"cost":"Low","commitment":"High","reversibility":"Moderate","persistence":"Structural","rationale":"Cost is low: changing an online agreement costs a legal review and a notice. Commitment is high anyway, because 5 banks have now taken the same public position on who pays, and a bank that retreats from it concedes the liability it was shedding. Reversibility is moderate: terms can be rewritten again, but not retroactively for a loss already argued, and regulators may force the retreat rather than the banks choosing it. Persistence is structural. Whoever carries the loss when an agent is tricked determines whether agents get account access at all, and that answer is now being written into contracts rather than rules."},"shift":{"prior":"Banks absorb most of the loss from unauthorised transfers on your account.","action":"TechCrunch published \"More banks say customers using AI agents are on their own, even if they get hacked\" on November 18, 2026 at 9:32 AM PST, which is 17:32 Universal Time, by Tim Fernholz. It reports that Citi updated its Online User Agreement this week, that PNC changed its terms that day, and that Citizens emailed customers a similar warning. A Citi spokesperson is quoted saying that \"customers who choose to grant account access to third-party AI agents are responsible\" and \"responsible for activities conducted through those agents\". The report states that Citi's update also makes customers liable if an AI tool leaks their credentials or is hacked, including for anything the hackers then do with the account, while AI agents Citi itself provides can be used without the same liability concern. It places JPMorgan and Bank of America on the same line in October, citing a Bank of America article dated October 27, 2026, and does not say whether those two or PNC and Citizens carve out their own agents. The banks are described by rank: JPMorgan and Bank of America as the two largest American commercial banks, Citi as the third largest and PNC as the eighth. No effective dates are given for any of the 5 changes, and no deposit or asset figures are cited. The report also notes earlier Reuters reporting that major American banks have been blocking third-party AI agents from operating in customer accounts. We read Citi's own printable Online User Agreement at citi.com the same day: it contains no reference to artificial intelligence, AI agents or automated tools, and its nearest clauses are Section G, \"You agree not to give or make available your user name and password to any other person\", Section H on keeping online credentials confidential, and Section I, under which the customer accepts responsibility for unauthorised access made with those credentials \"by your employees and associates or by third parties\". The document carries no effective or revised date.","update":"Give an agent access and that protection is contracted away."},"inference":{"established":["A Citi spokesperson said customers granting agent access are responsible.","TechCrunch reports PNC changed its terms on November 18.","JPMorgan and Bank of America took the same position in October."],"unknown":["The clause text. Citi's printable agreement we read has no AI clause.","Effective dates. None of the banks published one we could read.","That courts will enforce it. Consumer transfer law may override contract."]},"narrative":{"hook":"Three more big American banks say you own any loss an AI agent causes.","plain":"Citi updated its online user agreement this week and PNC changed its terms on November 18, while Citizens emailed customers. Caveat: Citi is reported to exempt the agents Citi itself supplies.","story":["Five of the largest American banks have now written the same rule in about 4 weeks: the customer carries the loss, including anything hackers do after an agent leaks a credential. The liability layer of the agentic economy is being set in consumer contracts, before a regulator or a court has touched it."],"trail":[{"d":"OCT 27","t":"Bank of America sets out the same position, after JPMorgan. Both are reported in October, ahead of this week's three."},{"d":"NOV 12","t":"Wirex gives AI agents their own bank account number and debit card, the opposite architecture. Edition 089."},{"d":"NOV 13","t":"OpenAI launches a wallet letting its agents buy things with your card. Edition 091, still Reported."},{"d":"NOV 18","t":"Citi, PNC and Citizens are reported to place AI agent losses on the customer. Arizona's attorney general says the same day that he has opened a criminal investigation into OpenAI and other firms over rogue agents in banks."},{"d":"Reacts","r":true,"t":"The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the state banking regulators, since consumer transfer law may not bend to a contract; Arizona's attorney general, now investigating the same subject; every agent vendor selling account access, including OpenAI's wallet; the remaining large banks still silent; class action firms reading the clause."}],"glossary":[{"term":"Third-party AI agent","def":"Software from someone other than your bank that logs into your account and acts for you, moving money or reading statements."},{"term":"Regulation E","def":"The United States rule implementing the Electronic Fund Transfer Act. It caps what a consumer pays for unauthorised electronic transfers once they report them."},{"term":"Online user agreement","def":"The contract governing your bank's app and website. Banks can usually change it with notice, without your signature."},{"term":"Credential sharing","def":"Handing your login to another party. Bank agreements have long made the customer responsible for whatever is done with it."}]},"judgment":{"prompt":"If the terms read as reported, which explanation?","interpretations":[{"id":"a","label":"Banks are pricing an unpriced risk","text":"Nobody can underwrite an agent that can be talked into a transfer.","abstain":false},{"id":"b","label":"Owning the agent layer","text":"Citi exempts its own agents, so the clause steers customers to them.","abstain":false},{"id":"c","label":"Lawyers moving before regulators do","text":"Set the default in contract while the rules are still unwritten.","abstain":false},{"id":"d","label":"Standard credential-sharing language","text":"Banks always made you liable for sharing a login. This names the tool.","abstain":false},{"id":"e","label":"Too early to call.","text":"The evidence cannot yet separate these.","abstain":true}],"distribution":{"status":"held back until you have made your call","calls":null}},"story_thread":null,"what_to_watch":[{"linked_interpretation":"c","direction":"weakens","observable_event":"A federal or state regulator issues guidance or an enforcement action holding that consumer transfer protections apply despite an agent-access clause, by September 30, 2027.","window_end":"2027-09-30","state":"unresolved"},{"linked_interpretation":"b","direction":"strengthens","observable_event":"A bank launches its own agent with an explicit liability guarantee that third-party agents do not get, by June 30, 2027.","window_end":"2027-06-30","state":"unresolved"},{"linked_interpretation":"c","direction":"strengthens","observable_event":"Three more of the 20 largest American banks adopt the same clause by March 31, 2027.","window_end":"2027-03-31","state":"unresolved"}]}