Reported 5 Oct 2026 · Governance A one-minute read

4 AI companies testified under oath in New York; Musk's ignored the subpoena.

On October 5 all 51 New York City council members questioned OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and Meta under subpoena. SpaceXAI did not appear, and the Speaker said the city is pursuing legal action.

Until now

AI oversight was a question for Congress, the states and Brussels.

Now

A city council can compel testimony, and will sue to get it.

Why it matters

No legislature had put the frontier laboratories under oath before. A city did it, and 4 of the 5 came. The one that stayed away now faces a petition in state court. Municipal subpoena power is slow and local, but it is real, and it does not need Congress to act first.

Established

  • The Council subpoenaed 5 AI companies on September 28 for the October 5 hearing.
  • 4 companies appeared and testified under oath; SpaceXAI did not appear.
  • Speaker Julie Menin said the city is pursuing the matter in court.

Not established

  • That any bill passed. The 10-bill package was heard, not voted.
  • What the witnesses said precisely. We have not read a transcript.
  • That a court will enforce it. No petition is on a public docket yet.
The five-minute readThe record, the timeline, the weight and 6 sources

The record

Reported, not verified: council.nyc.gov would not load from here, and no transcript or video record is published yet. The hearing, the subpoenas and the Speaker's statement come from 5 outlets, among them City and State New York, amNewYork, Fortune and La Voce di New York. The dated verification event is October 31, 2026: a Council press release, a published transcript, or a petition filed in the New York State Supreme Court naming SpaceXAI.

Monday October 5, 2026, at City Hall. The format was a Committee of the Whole, all 51 council members sitting together, the first since 2022, reported to have run 14 panels. Who testified for the companies: Morgan Dwyer, OpenAI's head of policy development and operations; Logan Graham, Anthropic's head of frontier AI research; Shane Cahill, Meta's director for privacy and AI legislation; and Alice Friend for Google. SpaceXAI, Elon Musk's company, did not appear. 3 former laboratory researchers gave evidence, 2 under subpoena: Jacob Coxon, formerly of OpenAI and Anthropic, who said "on the current path, I think it is more likely than not that humanity loses control of these AIs and it could end in human extinction"; Daniel Kokotajlo, formerly of OpenAI, who called current safety measures "duct tape that will fall off later"; and Alex Turner, formerly of Google DeepMind, who put the chance of an eventual AI takeover at roughly 1 in 3. The refusals are the record. No company representative would put a number on the chance of catastrophic harm, commit that failing an independent safety test would block a release, confirm it carries insurance against catastrophic risk, or accept legal liability for serious harm. Dwyer is quoted saying "I don't know. I also don't think it matters whether it's 1% or 10% or 20% chance of something catastrophic or wrong." Speaker Julie Menin, a former regulatory lawyer, led the questioning and said the representatives "can't seem to answer some of the most basic, rudimentary questions." On catastrophe: "To say you don't know and it doesn't matter is flippant at best." On SpaceXAI: "we are pursuing legal action," confirming that means court. The package includes external validation before deployment in the city, penalties reported at $25,000 per violation, human override requirements, whistleblower protections, 24-hour incident reporting, and a private right of action. Not established: the bill numbers, the subpoena's return date, and whether any petition has been filed.

How it got here

  1. Sep 16

    The Council announces a major hearing on the risks of AI, to examine whether New Yorkers need stronger protections.

  2. Sep 25

    The Council unveils a 10-bill AI package. The same week, 2 senators propose criminal liability for AI agent developers and California's Attorney General serves OpenAI with a subpoena. Editions 039's cards.

  3. Sep 28

    The Council authorises subpoenas from 9am after companies miss a Friday deadline to confirm. 4 agree to testify under oath. SpaceXAI, which never responded, is served and warned the Council can petition the New York State Supreme Court.

  4. Oct 5

    The hearing runs at City Hall. 4 companies answer; 3 former researchers warn about loss of control; no company will quantify catastrophic risk or accept liability; SpaceXAI is absent and Menin announces legal action.

Who has to react

SpaceXAI and Elon Musk, who must answer a subpoena or a petition; the New York State Supreme Court; the 4 companies that complied and now have sworn answers on a record; Governor Hochul and the state legislature, where the RAISE Act sits; Congress, which has held no comparable hearing; and every other large American city with subpoena power.

What to watch

  • Would strengthen itNew York City files a petition in state court to enforce the SpaceXAI subpoena, or the Council passes any bill from the 10-bill package, by March 31, 2027.
  • Would weaken itThe subpoena lapses with no court filing and no bill passes, or a state or federal measure preempts city AI rules, by June 30, 2027.
  • Would strengthen itAnother United States city or county subpoenas an AI company to testify, by December 31, 2027.

Why it weighs this much

Signal strength
CostLow
CommitmentMedium
ReversibilityModerate
PersistenceMonths

Cost is low. A hearing costs a day of council time, and the companies sent policy staff rather than founders. Commitment is medium: subpoenas were authorised, served and partly obeyed, and a Speaker who says in public that she is going to court has made that hard to drop quietly. Reversibility is moderate, because a petition can be withdrawn and a bill package can die in committee. Persistence is months, not years: the Council's term and the bills' progress both run on a short clock, and nothing here has the force of law yet. Scored modestly on purpose.

The words

Committee of the Whole
A hearing of every member of a legislature at once, rather than one committee. New York City's Council last held one in 2022.
Subpoena
A legal order to appear and answer. Ignoring one is not itself a crime; the body that issued it has to ask a court to enforce it.
Private right of action
A clause letting an ordinary person sue over a breach of a law, without waiting for a regulator to act. It multiplies enforcement.

Sources

Your call

If the petition is filed, which explanation do you believe?

A call is final. Other people's calls show after yours.

8 contributions. Thank you.

You have built
a record here.

Keep it: create an account to verify your contributions and put your name to the answers you choose. Your record stays yours.

Keep my record ↗
Optional: help show whose perspectives are missing
Kept with your answers under a random id, never with your name. Used for one thing: showing you, on your record, where you stand next to people like you, once at least 20 of them have answered.

Add your signature

Stand behind your judgment.

Create an account to attach your name to this answer. Your other answers show no name unless you sign them too.

Sign up to add your name ↗

Already have an account?